Skip to content
← All articles
Growth

Business Coach Vs Peer Group Vs Doing It Alone: What Owners At $250K To $3M Actually Need

Key Takeaways

  • Doing it alone, a peer group and a business coach each have real strengths and real gaps.
  • Books and courses work well when you already know what to work on.
  • A peer group gives you people in your corner but may not see what is stuck in your business.
  • At $250K to $3M the problem is rarely effort. It is usually the owner sitting in the middle of everything.
  • Find your step first. If you can say yes at your step, keep going. If you get stuck on a no, get help.

If your business is doing somewhere between $250K and $3M, you've probably wondered if you need a coach.

Or a mastermind. Or if you should just keep figuring it out yourself.

I'm a coach, so you'd expect me to say you need one. I'm not going to say that. Not everyone does.

I've also been on the other side of this. I built and sold a marketing agency I ran for about seven years. I've run sales teams. And I've coached hundreds of owners. I've learned from books, from peers and from people further down the road than me.

Here's an honest comparison so you can decide for yourself.

The Three Options

There are basically three ways owners at this stage get better.

Doing it alone. Books, podcasts, YouTube, courses and trial and error.

A peer group. Owners who meet regularly to share what's working and hold each other to it. Some are faith based. Some aren't.

A business coach. Someone who has built businesses and helps you figure out what's stuck and what to do about it.

Each one has real strengths. Each one has gaps.

Doing It Alone

What's good: It costs the least. You go at your own pace. And there's a lot of good material out there.

A lot of what I teach started in a book. Profit First is Mike Michalowicz's. The time audit comes from Dan Martell. Sunday planning and the Friday Review come from Darren Hardy. I'm not shy about that. Good ideas are worth borrowing.

What's hard: You don't know what you don't know. You can read a hundred books and still work on the wrong thing. Most owners try to fix one piece, like more marketing, when the real problem is somewhere else.

And it's lonely. Nobody sees the decisions you make at ten at night.

When it works: You have time and discipline. You know your next step. The business is growing in a healthy way.

A Peer Group

What's good: You're not alone anymore. "As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another" (Proverbs 27:17).

Hearing from owners a few steps ahead of you is valuable. So is posting your one next move where people can see it, and having them ask next week whether you did it.

What's hard: Peers can tell you what worked for them. They may not be able to see what's going on in your business. Advice comes from every direction at once. And sometimes a group becomes a place to talk instead of a place to act.

When it works: You mostly know what to do. What you need is perspective, encouragement and people who will hold you to it.

A Business Coach

What's good: A good coach sees what you can't see from inside the business. They help you find the one thing that matters most right now and keep you on it. They bring a framework, so you work on the right thing in the right order instead of guessing.

What's hard: It's an investment of time and money. A bad fit wastes both. And a coach with only one playbook may hand you advice built for a very different business.

When it works: You're stuck. You've tried the obvious things. You need someone to help you diagnose the problem and build a plan.

What Owners At $250K To $3M Usually Need

At this stage the problem is rarely effort. You're already working hard.

The problem is usually that you've become the bottleneck. Everything runs through you, and the family gets what's left.

I saw this up close in sales. I took a sales division from $100K to $150K a month to $300K a month. It didn't happen because I worked harder. It happened because we built the team. Every seat had a clear outcome, a playbook and one person who owned it.

That's what most owners at your size need. Not more hustle. A clear picture of where the business is stuck, the right next step, and people around them so they aren't carrying it alone.

Moses had this problem. His father in law Jethro watched him handle the people's disputes from morning until evening. Then he said, "What you are doing is not good. You and these people who come to you will only wear yourselves out" (Exodus 18:17 to 18).

Moses was faithful and hardworking. He still needed an outside voice to see it.

Find Your Step First

Before you decide on any kind of help, figure out where you actually are. Here's the quick check I give owners. Answer yes or no. Your step is the first one where you answer no to either question.

Clear. Can you tell me last month's revenue, expenses and profit from memory? Do you know exactly what you need to take home each month?

Predictable. Do you know where next month's customers will come from? Do your prices leave a healthy margin on every job?

Repeatable. Is the way you do the work written down? Has someone on your team delivered a job start to finish without you?

Free. Did someone other than you close a sale in the last 30 days? Could you take a full month off without revenue dipping?

Sellable. Are your books clean enough for a buyer to read? Would a buyer pay for anything beyond your equipment and your name?

If you landed on a step and you know how to get those two questions to yes, you may not need a coach. Keep going. Read. Find a couple of owners you trust. Do the work.

If you landed on a step and you've been stuck there for a while, that's when outside help usually pays for itself.

Free AuditThe Five Area Audit

Twenty five questions that show you where the business is really stuck.

Take The Audit Free

When You Do Not Need A Coach

I want to be straight with you here. You probably don't need a coach if:

  • You know exactly what to do next and you're doing it.
  • You can say yes to both questions at your step and you're working on the next one.
  • You don't have a few hours a week to act on what you learn. Coaching only works if you do the work between calls.
  • You want someone to do it all for you. That's a different kind of help.

How The Impact Freedom Accelerator Combines Both

The Impact Freedom Accelerator is a room for Christian owners of established businesses who've become the bottleneck. I built it to give you the coach side and the peer side together.

It starts with your Deep Dive. We take an honest look at your life and all five areas of your business: marketing, sales, delivery, finance and people. You walk away with your step on the roadmap, your top 3 for the next 90 days and your first action already written.

Every week we get on a live call. We start with wins, then hot seats where I work on someone's business live, then one teaching topic. Between calls you can post in the community and get feedback from me and the group. After a hot seat, you post your one next move in Wins so the room can cheer you on and hold you to it. You can post a prayer request too. You don't have to carry it alone.

Nathan Bot, an AI coach that knows your business and your step, answers questions any time of day.

Here are a few results from owners who did the work. Individual results, not typical or guaranteed.

  • Scott Vogeli, an electrical contractor in Sacramento, went from $40K to $50K months to a $250K month after getting clear on his offer.
  • Drew Wright's music school in Baltimore reached a record 448 students.
  • Penny Petridis brought in $30K up front plus $7K a month recurring in 30 days, working about 15 hours a week.
  • Laurie Hammer, a health coach, grew nearly 5x in a month.

You can read more of their stories on the testimonials page. Jeff Aronheim also talked with me about how working with more than one coach changed how he led his team. You can read that in Why Having 3 Coaches Created Massive Business Growth.

How To Decide This Week

Here's a simple exercise. It takes about fifteen minutes.

1. Find your step. Use the ten questions above, or take the Five Area Audit. It's twenty five yes or no questions and shows you which step you're on and what I'd work on first.

2. Name the one thing. Write down the one problem that, if it were fixed, would change your business most this year.

3. Ask if you know how to fix it. If yes, do it alone or with peers. If no, you probably need someone who can help you diagnose it.

4. Ask if you're carrying it alone. If yes, find people. A peer group, a coach with a community around it, or even two owners you meet with once a month.

5. Pray and decide. Talk it over with your spouse. Pray about it. Then make the call and give it 90 days before you second guess it.

Try It Free For 7 Days

If the Accelerator sounds like a fit, you can try it free for 7 days. Look around. Join a live call. See if it's right for you.

If you stay and don't love it in your first 30 days, the Love It Or Leave It guarantee gets you a full refund.

If you'd like to learn more first, start on the apply page.

Either way, don't keep carrying it alone.

Common Questions

Do I Need A Business Coach?

Not always. If you know your next step and you are taking it, you may not. If everything runs through you and you have tried the obvious fixes, outside help usually pays off.

What Is The Difference Between A Business Coach And A Peer Group?

A peer group gives you perspective, encouragement and accountability from other owners. A coach helps diagnose what is stuck in your specific business and builds a plan with you. Many owners benefit from both.

When Is It Better To Grow A Business On Your Own?

When you have the time and discipline, you know the next step, and the business is healthy. Many owners reach $250K this way.

What Should A Christian Business Owner Look For In A Coach?

Someone who has built businesses, uses a clear framework, cares about your family and faith as well as your revenue, and is honest about whether you are a fit.

How Do I Decide Which Option Is Right For Me?

Name the one thing that would change your business most this year. If you know how to fix it, work alone or with peers. If you do not, a coach can help. If you are carrying it alone, find people either way.

Filed UnderGrowthMindset

Scale Your Business So It Funds Your Calling

If everything in your business still runs through you, join the Impact Freedom Accelerator or grab the free tools I use with members.

Want 1:1 Help? Talk With Me First
Nathan Newberry
Nathan Newberry Business Advisor, Sales Leader And Former Pastor

Nathan Newberry is a business advisor, sales leader and former pastor. He helps Christian owners of established businesses scale so the business makes more money, needs less of them, and funds their calling. He built and sold a marketing agency, has interviewed hundreds of business advisors, and leads the Impact Freedom Accelerator. More about Nathan