Who To Hire First To Get Off The Tools: Assistant, Ops Manager Or Second In Command
Key Takeaways
- Hire to buy back your time, not to grow, and know your Buyback Rate before you hire anyone.
- Run a two week time audit and look for the red, low value clusters. Those are your first job description.
- Climb the ladder in order: admin first, then the person who runs delivery, and leadership last.
- Ask whether AI or a simple tool can take part of the work before you add a person.
- Write a scorecard with results, not tasks, before you write the job post.
You're on the tools all day. You write quotes at night. You answer the phone from the top of a ladder. And somewhere in there you're supposed to run a business.
So you know you need help. The question is who.
An assistant? An operations manager? Someone to be your number two?
I've coached a lot of owners through this exact decision. The mistake I see most isn't hiring a bad person. It's hiring a good person for the wrong seat. The money goes out, the week doesn't change, and the owner decides hiring doesn't work.
It does work. You just hire in the right order, for the right reason.
Hire To Buy Back Your Time
Dan Martell has a line I love. "Don't hire to grow your business. Hire to buy back your time."
That's the frame for every hire. Each person you bring on should hand you back hours. Then you put those hours into the work only you can do.
I learned this running sales. When I took a sales division from $100K to $150K a month to $300K a month, it wasn't because I worked more calls myself. It was because I built the team. I've said it for years. The CEO has two jobs. Keep casting the vision. And recruit, hire and keep great people.
For me there's a stewardship piece too. Your time is one of the things you've been trusted with. Spend it on purpose.
Know Your Buyback Rate
Before you hire anybody, find out what an hour of your time is actually worth.
Here's the math I give every owner. Take your income for the year. All of it. Salary, profit, distributions and the perks the business pays for. Divide by 2,000 hours. Then divide by 4.
That's your Buyback Rate.
Say you take home $200,000 all in. That's $100 an hour. A quarter of that is $25. So any task you could hand to someone for $25 an hour or less, and you're still doing it, is costing you money.
Why divide by 4? Because you want at least a 4x return on every hour you hand off.
Run A Two Week Time Audit
Most owners tell me they know where their time goes. Almost none of them are right.
So track it. Set a timer for every 15 minutes and write down what you did. Not what you meant to do. What you did. Do it for two full work weeks.
Mark each block green if it gave you energy, yellow if it was neutral and red if it drained you. Then give it a dollar rating from 1 to 4 for how much value it actually created.
At the end, total your hours by category. Email. Scheduling. Quotes. Callbacks. Invoices. Fixing stuff.
What you're looking for is clusters of red, low dollar time. Those clusters are a job description waiting to be written.
Then finish this sentence for each part of the business. "The work slows down because..." The one that ends with "because I'm the only one who can do it" is your bottleneck. That's the seat.
Climb The Hiring Ladder In Order
Martell calls this the Replacement Ladder. I teach it as the order you hire in. Each rung frees you up for the next one.
1. Admin. An assistant who owns the inbox, the calendar and the small stuff. 2. Delivery. Someone who runs the jobs, the crews and the callbacks. 3. Marketing. Someone who keeps the leads coming. 4. Sales. Someone who runs the estimates and the follow up. 5. Leadership. Someone who owns strategy and outcomes with you.
Now look at your three options against that ladder.
The assistant is rung one. That's why it's the first hire I recommend most. A good assistant doesn't need to know your trade. They need to be organized, reliable and kind on the phone. And it doesn't have to start full time. A few hours a week on the two or three things that drain you most is a real start.
The operations manager lives on the delivery rung. You need one when admin is handled but every job still runs through you. Crews call you with every question. Every callback lands on your phone. The schedule lives in your head.
The second in command is the top rung. Owners want this one most. They usually need it last. A leader needs seats to lead, numbers to watch and playbooks to run. Hire one into chaos and they either leave or turn into the most expensive assistant you've ever had.
Three rules keep the ladder honest.
Start at admin. Skip it and your inbox and calendar keep eating the time of every person you hire after.
One owner per rung. If two people share it, you still own it in your head.
Don't climb until the rung below holds without you. If delivery still needs you every day, a marketing hire just sends more work into a jammed system.
Your revenue keeps you honest too. Under $250K, the usual first seat is part time admin plus AI tools. From $250K to $500K, delivery usually runs through you, so the next seat is a delivery lead or your first specialist. Between $1M and $3M, the team is waiting on you for decisions, and that's where a sales lead and a true operations manager make sense. Leadership seats come after that. These are rules of thumb. Adjust for your margins.
Ask If AI Can Do It First
Before you add a person, look at your red clusters and ask one question. Can a tool or AI take part of this?
Drafting email replies. Meeting notes. Scheduling and reminders. A lot of that can go to AI or a simple automation now.
You're still going to hire. This just makes sure the person you bring on spends their day on work that actually needs a person. Relationships. Judgment. Anything where a mistake costs real money or trust. A lot of times it means you can afford one great hire where you were about to make two average ones.
Your first hire, what to hand off first, and how to buy your time back.
Write The Scorecard Before The Job Post
When your time audit, your bottleneck and your revenue stage all point at the same seat, write it down.
Start with a short role brief. The seat name, in plain words. What comes off your plate, with hours per week. What great looks like in 90 days. And a budget at or below your Buyback Rate math.
Then turn it into a scorecard. The key is to write results, not tasks.
"Follows up with leads" is a task. "Every new lead gets a first touch in under 5 minutes during business hours" is a result. A person can hit a result. They can only guess at a task.
Give each result a number. "Good" is a feeling. A number is a target.
What To Do This Week
Here's what I'd do in the next seven days.
Work out your Buyback Rate. Last year's real income, divided by 2,000, divided by 4. Write it at the top of a page.
List ten tasks from this week. Circle the ones you could hand off at or below that rate.
Start your two week time audit. Tomorrow morning. Fifteen minute timer. Color and dollar rating on every block.
Find your rung. Admin, delivery, marketing, sales or leadership. Be honest about which one is holding you up.
Write the role brief. Seat name, hours off your plate, what great looks like in 90 days, budget.
I put the whole first hire process in the EA Playbook. What to hand off first, what a part time start looks like and how to train someone once so the work doesn't bounce back to you.
If you want to hear how someone who does this for a living thinks about it, read how Dr. Michael Neal helps founders buy back time by hiring the right people. And if you know a coach wrestling with the same question, send them this post on when to hire your first person in a coaching business. Different business. Same principle.
The First Hire Is Really About You
One more thing, and it's the part nobody likes.
The first hire isn't just about getting help. It's deciding you're going to be the owner, not just the best tech on the crew. That's an identity shift. It's harder than any job post.
And then you have to protect what you bought back. Martell calls it Audit, Transfer, Fill. Most owners do the first two. They hand the work off and the free hours fill right back up with busywork. Block those hours on your calendar for selling, leading and building the next layer.
What you do with your hours matters more than how many you put in. One of our members, Penny Petridis, brought in $30K up front plus $7K a month recurring in 30 days while working about 15 hours a week. Your business is different. The lesson isn't.
Where The Impact Freedom Accelerator Fits
This is Step 4 of the Impact Freedom Roadmap. We call it Free. The one question is simple. Does your team run it?
Inside the Impact Freedom Accelerator, the Leadership And Hiring course walks you through this exactly. Hire To Buy Back Your Time gives you your Buyback Rate and the ladder. Know The Roles You Need runs the two week audit and the role brief. Build The Scorecard Before The Job Post turns that into a scorecard you can hire against. NATHANbot, our AI coach, drafts each one with you, and you bring it to the weekly coaching call with me to pressure test it.
It's my coaching community on Skool for Christian business owners who are ready to get out of the day to day.
You can try it free for 7 days. After that you're still covered by our 30 day Love It Or Leave It refund.
If that sounds like the next step, come take a look at the Impact Freedom Accelerator.
Common Questions
Who Should I Hire First In A Small Service Business?
For most owners it is an assistant. The inbox, phones, calendar and invoices eat more of your week than you think, and if you skip this rung those same tasks keep eating the time of every person you hire after.
When Should I Hire An Operations Manager?
When admin is handled and the work still runs through you. Crews call you with every question and every callback lands on your phone. That is the delivery rung, and it usually shows up somewhere between $250K and $1M, with a full operations manager closer to $1M to $3M.
Should My First Hire Be A Second In Command?
Usually not. A leader needs seats to lead, numbers to watch and playbooks to run. Don't climb to that rung until the ones below it hold without you.
How Do I Know What I Can Afford To Pay?
Work out your Buyback Rate. Take your all in income for the year, divide it by 2,000 hours, then divide by 4. Any task you could hand off at or below that rate is costing you money while you keep doing it.
Scale Your Business So It Funds Your Calling
If everything in your business still runs through you, join the Impact Freedom Accelerator or grab the free tools I use with members.
Want 1:1 Help? Talk With Me First